By Frank Lee Park — Editor, Park Signpost
John Adams stood in a Boston courtroom in 1770 and reminded the jury that "facts are stubborn things; and whatever may be our wishes, our inclinations, or the dictates of our passion, they cannot alter the state of facts and evidence." The fashionable story of the Crusades is a wish dressed up as a fact. Here is the evidence.
The Crusades were not random wars of aggression. They were, in their origins, defensive ones.
One Christendom, Five Thrones
In early Christianity there were five great centers of authority: Rome, Alexandria, Constantinople, Antioch, and Jerusalem. Each had a bishop who administered a large region, both politically and religiously. The origins were apostolic, and these cities were the core seats of Christian authority.
Then Islam rose out of the Arabian Peninsula in the early 600s. Almost immediately after consolidating power in Arabia, the new Muslim state launched rapid military expansion against its neighbors from 632 onward. Within a generation, Islam had taken three of the five patriarchal seats — Antioch, Jerusalem, and Alexandria — in the 7th century.
The armies of the caliphate conquered the Iberian Peninsula (modern Spain and Portugal) and were at Tours, France, by 732, where Charles Martel's Frankish army finally halted their advance into western Europe (Britannica).
Poor Richard put it plainly: "Little strokes fell great oaks." It took the Spaniards nearly 800 years — 711 to 1492 — to expel the invaders. The Reconquista was the western front of a long defense; the Crusades were the eastern one.
The East Called for Help
By 1095, the Seljuk Turks — an Islamic power carrying the advance of Muslim expansion into Christian lands — had shattered the Byzantine frontier. Emperor Alexios I Komnenos of Constantinople sent envoys to Pope Urban II, formally appealing for military support at the Council of Piacenza in March 1095 (Wikipedia). That November, at the Council of Clermont, Urban II called the First Crusade (Britannica).
Poor Richard said it best: "God helps them that help themselves." The East asked; the West answered. Eastern armies existed, but they were not sufficient on their own to reverse the onslaught — which is precisely why Alexios appealed to the West. The bulk of the Crusaders came from Western Christendom, a mobilization to defend Christians, Christian pilgrims, and Christian territory, exactly as the Byzantine plea framed it.
Christians of East and West still thought of themselves as belonging to a common Christendom under severe external pressure. Franklin had a word for that arrangement at another crisis, eleven centuries later: we must all hang together, or assuredly we shall all hang separately. By the era of the Fourth Crusade, in 1204, that common Christendom had frayed badly — hence the horrific sacking of Constantinople, a wound Christendom inflicted on itself.
The Sins, Honestly Weighed
The Rhineland pogroms of 1096 were indefensible — and this editor will not paper over them. But they were not the goal of the Crusades, nor were they sanctioned by the Church. They were carried out by irregular mobs of the so-called People's Crusade, most infamously under Count Emicho of Flonheim (Wikipedia). Urban II did not authorize anti-Jewish violence; bishops and local church authorities tried to protect Jews, sheltering them in palaces and churches — at Speyer, at Worms, at Mainz — sometimes at the cost of their own safety (Medievalists.net). Well done is better than well said, and those bishops did well.
The Long Ottoman Shadow
The Ottomans took the Balkans, and Constantinople herself fell in 1453. With that fall, only Rome remained in Christian hands of the five original seats.
Out of that wreckage comes one of history's stubborn men. Taken hostage by the Ottomans as a boy, along with his younger brother Radu, Vlad Țepeș of Wallachia returned home and ruled from 1456 to 1462. When Sultan Mehmed II marched a massive army into Wallachia to unseat him, Vlad blunted the invasion with scorched earth and his daring Night Attack at Târgoviște — one of the most famous episodes of the age (Wikipedia). Franklin said energy and persistence conquer all things; Vlad supplied both.
But his wins were not permanent. The Ottomans installed his brother Radu — raised at the sultan's court, converted to Islam, and a favorite of the Sultan himself — who led Ottoman-backed forces against his own blood (Medievalists.net). Vlad died in battle in late 1476 or early 1477, fighting Ottoman-backed rivals in a final bid for his throne.
Yet even then, Wallachia remained a Christian principality under Ottoman suzerainty — tributary, not annexed and subjugated. Without Vlad's resistance, Wallachia could easily have been swallowed whole, as Bulgaria, Bosnia, and Serbia were.
The Ottomans pressed against central Europe for over a century and a half. They laid siege to Vienna in 1529, and were hurled back for good at the second siege in 1683 — 154 years later — by the armies of Poland's John III Sobieski and the Holy League (Britannica).
The Moral
A century and a half of patient resistance saved Vienna. Eight centuries of little strokes felled the oak in Spain. Defense, patience, and stubborn facts — things you don't learn in school these days about "colonisers."
__________________________________________
Frank Lee Park keeps his ink pot full and his counsel his own. Courtesy costs nothing; neither does a fact.